Journal of Iranian Cultural Research

Journal of Iranian Cultural Research

Introducing a mixed method for the analysis of urban visual culture texts: A case study on a mural at Vanak square,, Tehran

Document Type : Scientific Research Manuscript

Authors
Mohammad Rashid Soofi 1
A. Ravadrad 2
1 Professor of Social Communications, Faculty of Sociology, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
2 PhD Candidate of Social Communications, Faculty of Sociology, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
10.22035/jicr.2020.2190.2701
Abstract
This paper aims to introduce a mixed research method for the analysis, reading, and interpretation of urban visual culture texts. To reach this goal, mural have been chosen as the most outstanding urban visual text. In order to do a case study, one of the outstanding wall-paintings located in Tehran`s Vanak square, has been selected to be analyzed by a mixed method. The analysis of the visual text has been done in two stages including semiology and discourse analysis. For the first stage, we used O`Toole`s semiotic method suitable for analyzing urban murals, and for the second stage, we employed Laclau and Mouffe`s discourse theory. Findings of the case study for the micro level showed that, key signifiers - as nodal points - of the text have been recognized as nature, city, man, and woman and the relationship and interaction between them have been distinguished in the form of binary oppositions such as nature (village)/city and man/woman. At the macro level, the main competitive discourses identified in the text, are Environmental Protection vs. Urban Sprawl and Masculism vs. Feminism, that are lively and actively in an antagonistic situation using their key signifiers. Finally, the dominant and hegemonic discourses through positive representation of their key signifiers can be considered as Environmental Protection and Masculism.
Keywords
semiotics
discourse analysis
visual culture
city
mural
Tehran

Subjects

Abdolhoseyni, A. (2005). Nešānehā-ye tasviri va edrāke basari [Visual signs and visual understanding]. Journal of Honarhā-ye Tajassomi/ Conceptual Arts, 23.
Akbari Motlagh, M. (2011). Barresi-ye ta`sir-e keyfiyat-e manzar-e šahri bar tabiin-e hoviyat-e šahri-ye pāytaxt-e ma`navi-ye Irān [Examination of the influence of the urban vision quality on the explanation of urban identity in Iran`s spiritual capital]. Presented at the First National Urban Branding Conference, Tehran, Iran. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/215587556
Aminzadeh Goharrizi, B., Sharifi, M. S., & Forughifar, M. (2014). Moqāyese-ye edrāk-e zibāyi-ye manzar-e šahri az nazar-e motaxasesān va kārbarān: Motāle`e-ye moredi-ye meydāne Adl-e Xomeyni-ye Mašhad [Comparisan of urban vision`s easthetic conception between experts and users: A case study on Mashhad`s Adle Khomeini Square]. Journal of Motāle`āt-e Šahri/Urban Studies, 10.
Bahmani Kazeruni, S., & Jalali, A. (2013). Ta`sir-e nešānehā va elemānha-ye šahri bar xānāyi-ye šahrhā: Nemune-ye moredi-ye šahre Širāz [Influence of urban signs and elements on cities` readability: A case study on Shiraz]. Presented at National Conference on Urban Beautification Elements, Tehrān, Iran.
Bani Asadi, M. A. (2013). Negāhi ejmāli beh naqāšiha-ye divari-ye šahre Tehrān: Motāle`e-ye zel`e jonubi-ye bozorgrāhe Resālat/ mahdude-ye pol-e Seyyed Xandān ta meydān-e Resālat[A glance at Tehran`s murals: A study on the southern side of Resalat highway/ from Seyyed Khandan bridge to Resalat square]. In M. Fadavi (Eds.), Frist Scientific Biennale`s Papers Collection on Urban Wall-painting and Environmental Graphics. Tehrān, Iran: Sāzmāne Zibāsāzi-ye Tehrān.
Barati, N., & Najafi Trojani, N. (2016). Arziyābi-ye nemād-e vorudi-ye šahrhā bar mabnā-ye mo`alefehā-ye kālbodi-ye tarāhi: Motāle`e-ye moredi-ye nemād-e vorudi-ye šarqi-ye šahre Qazvin [Evaluation of cities` entrance symbols based on design format factors: A case study on Qazvin`s eastern entrance symbol]. Journal of Motāle`āt-e Šahri/Urban Studies, 19, 81-91.
Baudrillard, J. (1994). Simulacra and simulation (S. F. Glaser, Trans.). MI: University of Michigan Press. (Original work published 1981)
Beygi, S., Purjafar, M., & Imani Naini, M. (2010). Barresi-ye ta`sire ruhi va ravāni-ye badanehā-ye šahri bar šahrvandān [Examination of the psychological influences of urban figures on citizens]. Journal of Modiriyate Šahri, 33, 201-216.
Brinkman, L. M. (2007). From apartheid to HIV/AIDS: The construction of memory, identity, and communication through public murals in South Africa (Unpublished MA thesis). Graduate College of Bowling Green State University.
Bryson, N. (1988). The gaze in the expanded field. In Hall Foster (Ed.), "Vision and Visuality".  New York: The New Press.
Connor, A. A. (2016). Juana Alicia: A case study of the artist as critical muralist (Unpublished MA thesis). San Jose State University.
De Rock, J., & Lichtert, K. (2008). Visual discourses of distinction: early Netherlandish painting as vehicle of social and political identity. Presented at IXe Conférence Internationale d’Histoire Urbaine.
Debord, Guy (2014). Jāme`e-ye namāyeš [La societe du spectacle] (Behruz Safdari, Trans.). Tehrān, Iran: Našre Āgah. (Original work published 1992)
Demytrie, D. A. (2000). A semiological analysis of urban space in transitional cultures: A case study of Tashkent`s City Centre (Unpublished MA thesis). University of Manitoba, Department of City Planning.
Foroutan, S., & Mahdavipur, H. (2015). Tahlile nešānehā-ye me`māri dar simā-ye šahre Bušehr [Analysis of the architectural signs used in the city of Busher`s vision]. Presented at Konferanse Beynomelali-ye Ensān, Me`māri, Mohandesi-ye Omrān, va Šahr/ International Conference on Human, Architecture, Civil Engineering, and City. Tabriz, Iran.
Ghazaiyan, M., & Haghighatbin, M. (2013). Honare zibasāzi-ye fazāye šahri ba ta`kid bardivarnegāri [Urban space beautification art with the emphasis on wall-painting]. In M. Fadavi (Eds.) the Frist Scientific Biennale`s Papers Collection on Urban Wall-painting and Environmental Graphics. Tehrān, Iran: Sāzmāne Zibāsāzi-ye Tehrān.
Golkar, K. (2013). Simā va manzareh šahri-ye Tehrān: Tahlili az barnāmeh rāhbordi-ye tarāhi-ye šahri va modiriyate manzare šahri-ye Tehrān [An analysis on Tehran`s strategic plan for urban designing and vision management]. Bi-Quarterly Journal of Nāmeh Me`māri va šahrsāzi/ Architecture and Urbanization, 10.
Gunawardena, G. M. W. L., Kubota, Y., & Fukahori, K. (2015). Visual complexity analysis using taxonomic diagrams of figures and backgrounds in Japanese residential streetscapes. Journal of Urban Studies Research, Volume 2015, Article ID 173862, 12 p.
Hall, S. (ed.) (1997). Representation: Cultural representations and signifying practices. London, Thousand Oaks, and New Delhi: Sage/Open University Press.
Hasanvand, M. K. (2014). Mozu` va mazmun dar divārnegāri-ye mo`āsere Tehrān [Subject and content in Tehran`s contemporary wall-painting]. In A. Kafshchiyan (Eds.), A Collection of Papers on Urban Wall-painting. Tehrān, Iran: Sāzemān-e Zibāsāzi-ye Šahre Tehrān.
Hess-Luttich, E. W. B. (2016). Urban discourse – city space, city language, city planning: Eco-semiotic approaches to the discourse analysis of urban renewal. Journal of Sign Systems Studies, 44 (1/2), 12-33.
Heywood, I. Sandywell, B. (ed.) (1999). Interpreting visual culture: Explorations in the hermeneutics of the visual. London: Routledge.
Howells, R. (2003). Visual culture. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Jamali, M. (2015). Moqadame`ei bar mafhum-e form va formalism dar honar-e modern [An introduction to the concept of form and formalism in modern art]. Journal of Jostārha-ye falsafi/ Phulosophical queries, 28, 5-33.
Jorgensen, M., & Phillips, L. (2010). Nazariye va Raveš dar tahlile goftmān [Theory and method in discourse analysis] (H. Jalili, Trans.). Tehran, Iran: Našre Ney.
Kafshchiyan M., A., & Rouyan, S. (2014). Barresi-ye divārnegāri-ye mo`āsere Tehrān (qabl va ba`d az enqelāb) [Examination of Tehrn`s contemporary wall-painting (pre-and-post revolution)]. Journal of Honarhā-ye Zibā, Me`māri va Šahrsāzi/ Fine Arts, Architecture and Urbanization, 33, 103-114.
Karami, S., Fakhrayi, A., Karami, S., & Rasouli, M. M. (2016). Arziyābi-ye me`yārha-ye mo`aser bar xaterehangizi va tasvirpaziri fazāhā-ye šahri: Nemuneh moredi-ye xiyābāne Vali`asre Tehrān [Evaluation of the effective criteria on memorability and imaginability of urban spaces: A case study on Tehran`s Valiasr Street]. Journal of Motāle`āte Mohiti-ye Haft Hesār/ Haft-Hesar Environmental Studies, 17, 35-44.
Kousari, M. (2015). Nešānešenāsi-ye šahri [Urban Semiotics]. Tehran, Iran: Našre Šahr.
Kowalewski, M. (2018). Images and spaces of port cities in transition. Space and Culture, 120633121878394. doi:10.1177/1206331218783940
Laclau, E. (1990). New reflections on the revolution of our time. London: Routledge.
Laclau, E., & Mouffe, C. (1985). Hegemony and socialist strategy: Towards a radical democratic politics. London: Verso.
Lawson, B. (2012). Zabāne fazā [The language of space] (A. Eynifar & F. Karimiyān, Trans.). Tehran, Iran: Teran Univarsity Press.
Linda, S., & Kolomyeytsev, A. (2014). Semiotics of the city’s pedestrian space. Magazine of Środowisko Mieszkaniowe, 13, 125-129.
Lindner, C. (2013). After-Images of the highrise city: visualizing urban change in modern New York. The Journal of American Culture, 36(2), 75–87.  doi:10.1111/jacc.12015
Lisiak, A. (2009). Disposable and usable pasts in central european cities. Culture Unbound: Journal of Current Cultural Research, 1(2), 431–452. doi:10.3384/cu.2000.1525.09125431
Lopez, T. L. G. (2009). Changes from the fall of a totalitarian visual discourse: New Examples from Metropolitan Lisbon. Presented at Arte Y Espacio Publico En Las Dictaduras Conference, Barcelona, September 2009.
Mirzoeff, N. (1999). An introduction to visual culture. London: Routledge.
Mokhtabad, S. M., Mohammadyarzadeh, S., & Shamsollahi, B. (2009). Jostāri bar ensānšenāsi/ nešānešenāsi-ye šahri va naqše ān dar xānāyi-ye fazāhā-ye šahri: Moredkāvi-ye šahre Esfahān [An inquiry on urban anthropology/ semiology and its role in readability of urban spaces: A case study on the city of Esfahan]. Journal of Motāle`āte Tose`eye Ejtemā`i-ye Irān / Iran`s Social Development Studies, 4, 31-69.
Motavali, M. (2010). Barresi va sanješe keyfiyate zibāyi dar manzare šahri bar asāse mafhume didhā-ye motavāli: nemune moredi-ye masire gardešgari-ye Dārābād-e Tehrān [Examination and Measurement of the easthetic quality of the urban vision based on sequential looks concept: A case study on touristic road of Darabad-Tehran]. Journal of Armanshahr, 5, 123-139.
Nadaliyan, A. (2014). Āsibšenāsi-ye divarnegarihā-ye Tehrān dar ta`āmol bā fazāhā-ye tasviri [Pathology of Tehran`s wall-painting in regard of visual spaces]. In A. Kafshchiyan Moghadam (Eds.), A Paper Collection on Urban Wallpainting. Tehran, Iran: Sāzmāneh zibāsāzi-ye šahre Tehrān.
Noble, C. (2004). A semiotic and visual exploration of graffiti and public space in Vancouver. Retrieved from https://www.graffiti.org/faq/noble_semiotic_warfare2004.html
Panahi, S., Bahrami S., N., & Kia, A. (2016). A semantic approach to urban graffiti from semiotics viewpoint. International Journal of Architecture and Urban Development, 6(1), 85-94.
Ravadrad, A., & Mahmudi, B. (1390/2011). Tasvir-e šahr-e Tehrān dar sinamā-ye dāstāni-ye Irān pas az enqelāb [Tehran`s image in Iranian post-revolution fictionalized cinema]. Journal of Tahqiqāt-e Farhangi-ye Irān/ Iran Cultural Research, 13, 1-26. doi: 10.7508/IJCR.2011.13.001
Ravadrad, A., & Mahmudi, B. (2015). Taxayol-e Tehrān: Motāle`ye manzare zehni-ye šahr dar sinamā-ye dahe-ye čehel-o panjāhe Irān [Tehran`s imagination: A study on mental vision of city in Iranian 60s and 70s cinema]. Journal of Tahqiqāt-e Farhangi-ye Irān/ Iran Cultural Research, 32, 53-90. doi: 10.7508/IJCR.2015.32.003
Robertson, L. M. (2017). Artspaces: Community perceptions of city beautification through murals in Dneton, Texas (Unpublished MS thesis). University of North Texas.
Rodriguez, K. D. (2014). Authorship and memory in Judy Baca's murals (Unpublished MA thesis). University of California, Riverside.
Rohani, H., & Beygzadeh, H. (2015). Erteqā-ye hoviyate simā–ye me`māri šahri bā ruykarde me`māri-ye zaminegerā: Motāle`ye moredi-ye xiyābāne Emām Xomeyni Yazd [Promotion of urban architecture identity with contextual architecture approach: A case study on Imam Khomeini Street of Yazd]. Presented at Sevvomin Konferānse Beynolmelali-ye Pažuhešhā-ye Kārbordi dar Mohandesi-ye Omrān, Me`māri, va Modiriyate Šahri/ 3rd International Conference on Applied Research in Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Management. Tehran, Iran.
Rojek, C. (2011). Motāle`āt-e farhangi [Cultural Studies] (P. Alavi, Trans.). Tehrān, Iran: Entešārāte Sāniyeh. (Original work published 2007)
Rose, G. (2001). Visual methodologies. London: Sage Publications Ltd.
Rostam Afshar, B., Gholamalizadeh, H. (2014). Nemādhā, nešānehā va hoviyate Eslāmi dar me`māri va šahrsāzi-ye Irān [Symbols, signs and Islamic identity in Iran`s architecture and urbanization]. Presented at Hamāyeše melli-ye me`māri, šahrsāzi va tose`e-ye pāyedār/ National Conference on architecture, urbanization, and sustainable development. Mašhad, Iran: Mo`asese-ye Āmuzeshe Āliye Xāvarān.
Sayafzadeh, A., Mirei, M., & Noudeh Farahani, M. (2013). Naqše keyfiyate manzare šahri dar ij šahri dar ijāde hayāte ejtemā`i va hoviyate makāni-ye šahrvandān: Motāle`ye moredi-ye bozorgrāhe Navvabe Tehrān [The role of urban vision quality in citizens` social life and locational identity: A case study on the Navvab highway in Tehran]. Journal of Šahre Irāni Eslāmi/ Iranian Islamic City Studies, 11, 29-40.  
Shortell, T., & Krase, J. (2010). Place, space, identity: A spatial semiotics of the urban vernacular in global cities. Presented at ESA Research Network Sociology of Culture Midterm Conference: Culture and the Making of Worlds, October.
Soltani, S. A. (2004). Tahlile goftman be masābehe nazariye va raveš [Discourse analysis as the theory and method]. Journal of Olume Siyāsi/ Political Sciences, 28, 153-180.
Sorur, H., Kashani Asl, A., Eslami, M., & Salahi S., V. (2014) Barresi-ye tasire nemādha va nešāneha-ye šahri dar tose`e-ye gardešgari:  Motāle`ye moredi-ye šahre Tabriz [Examination of the influence of the urban symbols and signs in tourism development: A case study on the city of Tabriz]. Journal of Barnamerizi va Tose`e-ye Gardešgari/ Planning and Tourism Development, 11, 118-140.
Tajbakhsh, K. (2015). Ārmān-e šahr: Fazā, hoviyat va qodrat dar andiše-ye ejtemā`i-ye mo`āser [The promise of the city: Space, identity, and politics in contemporary social thoght] (A. Khakbaz, Trans.). Tehrān, Iran: Našre Ney.
Talebi, F., Pilechiyan, A., & Ahmadi, V. (2014). Barresi-ye nešānehā-ye šahri-ye gozašteh barāye tadāvome xānāyi dar šahrsāzi-ye emruz: Nemuneh moredi-ye bāfte markazi-ye šahre Mašhad [Examination of last urban signs for the continuation of readability in today`s urbanization: A case study on centeral context of the city of Mashhad]. Presented at Hamāyeše Melli-ye Me`māri, Šahrsāzi va Tose`e-ye Pāyedār/ National Conference on Architecture, Urbanization, and Sustainable Development, Mašhad, Iran.
Torkashvand, A., & Majidi, S. (2013). Bāzšenāsi-ye barxi nešānehā dar fazāye šahri [Recognition of some sings in urban spaces]. Journal of Me`māri va Šahrsazi-ye Irān/ Iran`s Architecture and Urbanization, 6, 5-15.
Walker, J. A., & Chaplin, S. (2006). Farhange tasviri [Visual culture] (H. Garšāsbi & S. Xāmuš, Trans.). Tehran, Iran: Edare Kolle Pažuhešhā-ye Sedā va Simā.
Yanushkevich, I. (2014). Semiotics of social memory in urban space: The case of Volgograd (Stalingrad). International Journal of Cognitive Research in Science, Engineering and Education, 2(1), 43-50.
Yildirim, S. (2013). Urban semiotics and its impact on human behavior. An Unpublished Essay for Language and Other Communication Systems. University of Latvia.
Yuri, L. (2013). Nešānešenāsi va zibāšenāsi-ye sinemā [Semiotics and easthetics of Cinema] (M. Owhadi, Trans.). Teran, Iran: Soruš Press.
Zangi, B., Ayatollahi, H., & Fahimifar, A. (2012). Barresi-ye mowqe`iyate ejtemā`ye naqāši-ye divāri pas az enqelāb dar Irān bā ruykarde jāme`ešenāsi-ye Bourdieu [Examination of the social situation of Iran`s post-revolution wall-painting with sosiological approach of Bourdieu]. Journal of Negareh, 24, 85-101.
Send comment about this article
Enter Name.
Enter a valid email address.
Enter a vaid affiliation.
Enter comments (At leaset 10 words)
CAPTCHA Image
Enter Security Code Correctly.

  • Receive Date 17 January 2019
  • Revise Date 28 November 2019
  • Accept Date 09 December 2019